A judge sentenced a Columbus woman to 29 years to life in prison after she was convicted last week on murder and other charges in the death of her 5-year-old foster son.
A jury on Nov. 10 found Pammy Maye guilty of murder, tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse after a two-day trial. Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Mark Serrott sentenced Maye after hearing from Taylor's biological family members, who asked for Maye to receive life without parole.
Serrot called that the "easy sentence."
"I have seen a lot in 47 years as a lawyer. I've seen a lotta murders. I've had more than 100 murder cases here as a judge. If I just decided, you know, I'm going to sentence out of anger, that's what it would be," Serrott said.
Maye killed Darnell Taylor in Feb. 2024. Authorities say after killing the child, Maye disposed of his body in a storm drain. She then fled to the Cleveland suburb of Brooklyn, where she was arrested.
At the center of the trial was whether Maye was mentally insane when she killed the boy.
Serrott said he believed Maye was severely mentally ill. He cited medical reports used in the trial that said Maye was bipolar and has "major depression" but was faking some symptoms.
The jury declined to acquit Maye due to insanity. She found was competent to stand trial before it began.
Maye confessed her crimes to police. She told police she was frustrated with Taylor's behavior, saying the child ate snacks in his bed. She also told police where to find Taylor's body.
During the sentencing, Maye had several outbursts and told her lawyer, Sam Shamansky, she wanted to fire him. She called Shamansky the "anti-christ" at one point, arguing she thought Shamansky was working with prosecutors to convict her and claimed body-worn camera footage of police interviewing her was edited.
Shamansky called the allegation "ridiculous."
Serrott praised Shamansky as "the most preeminent lawyer in central Ohio" and explained to Maye that despite the evidence against her, Shanamsky argued the entire trial that Maye was mentally ill.
Shamansky never disputed Maye killed Taylor. during the trial. He told WOSU after the verdict that thejustice system doesn't work properly to care for mentally ill people like Maye.
Serrott argued back-and-forth with Maye Thursday, removed her from the courtroom at one point, and spoke with Shamansky and prosecutors for about an hour. He repeatedly warned Maye her conduct would impact the sentencing and told Maye firing Shamansky would be detrimental to her case.
When asked by Serrott to directly say she wanted to fire Shamansky, Maye remained silent. Serrott said he thought Maye was trying to put off the sentencing.
"You're not allowed to delay these proceedings," he told her.
Maye went on several tangents, claiming she was "under God's wrath" and that she was possessed by demons and visited by Jesus.
Serrott responded to her multiple times. One time he quipped "Well it's my day to punish you."
Serrott said he he'd never seen a sentencing like this in all of his 47 years as a lawyer and judge.
Dan Meyer, the director of the Franklin County Prosecutor's Office, argued Maye showed no genuine remorse. He pointed out that despite the outbursts on Thursday, Maye was on good behavior and "quiet as a door mouse" when the jury was in the courtroom deciding her fate during the trial.
Meyer told reporters after the sentencing that he respects the judge's rationale.
"Nothing's gonna bring Darnell Taylor back. And that's the toughest part of our job is just knowing that there's no prison sentence that she could ever do that would fix what she's done," Meyer said.
Maye didn't apologize on Thursday until just before Serrott gave the sentence. While she apologized, she told the many family members in the court room that they needed to forgive her if they want "eternal life."
"There was no right for what I had done. Because God said, Revenge is fine, said the Lord, but (Darnell Taylor) didn't deserve nothing. He didn't deserve it," Maye said. "I am so sorry. Yes, they are going to have to forgive me and they want eternal life."