Lack of Snow Plows Left Columbus Streets Covered, Spark Complaints

Listen to the Story

More than 12 hours after last week's snowstorm, Lane Avenue through Ohio State's campus remained unplowed.(Photo: Mandie Trimble)
More than 12 hours after last week's snowstorm, Lane Avenue through Ohio State's campus remained unplowed.(Photo: Mandie Trimble)

Columbus city officials have been getting an earful in the past week. More than 1,000 people called Columbus’s 311 line complaining about the city’s snow removal efforts after last week’s storm.


WOSU examines why Columbus streets were in such bad shape days after the snow stopped falling.

Last week’s storm was significant for central Ohio, Columbus got between five and seven inches of snow and a little bit of ice.

But as many suburban streets were clear about 12 hours after the storm, most in Columbus were still snow covered – even main roads.

MORE: All Sides with Ann Fisher examines the issue.

Cathy Hall, of Clintonville, pumped gas as she watched cars inch down the unplowed Olentangy River Road Thursday morning, 38 hours after the storm.

It’s one of the main arteries to get to Ohio State and everything so I was a little surprised that it wasn’t in better condition.

In some cases, it took city crews 40 hours to clear main roads. Unplowed residential streets forced Columbus City Schools to cancel classes for a third day while other districts returned to class after missing one.

Over on Maize Road, in North Linden, Keith Russell noted the snow on the busy street.

“You’d think as much traffic is on it, they’d keep it more clear because it is a busy road,” Russell said. “I mean, I think they ought to hit the side roads a little bit, but I guess they’re doing the best as they can do, I don’t know.”

So why does it take so long? First let’s look at the number of plows. In last week’s storm the city used 78 plows to clear all of the city’s 6,300 lane miles. That’s fewer plows than in comparable cities.

Take Kansas City, Missouri for example: same number lane miles, same average snowfall as Columbus. Kansas City put 240 plows on the street last week, more than triple what Columbus used.

And Kansas City does not have to plow state highways, which Columbus has to.

Sean Demory speaks for Kansas City Public Works department. He said their crews stick to city streets.

“It definitely gives us some more flexibility as far as what sort of coverage we can provide, and it allows us to meet the needs of our city a little more effectively,”he said.

Demory said two days after the storm all of the city’s streets were clear of the eight to 10 inches of snow they received.

As for why Columbus, and not the Ohio Department of Transportation, has to plow state Routes 315 and 23 and 33, state law mandates local municipalities take care of them if they’re inside city limits.

The city’s Public Service Planning and Operations administrator Patti Austin said Columbus and ODOT share some outlying plowing routes.

“It makes us more efficient. So, it’s not that we contract with ODOT and we do a bunch of their work and they don’t do a bunch of ours,” she said. “We trade back and forth based on who is most logical to complete that route based on whether they are out there anyway.”

It used to be worse. Columbus plows used to have to clear I-670, 70 and 71 within city limits.

Columbus did have some bad luck. For one thing, the brutal winter has depleted the city’s supply of salt, so crews are spreading it judiciously.

And Columbus was supposed to have another 27 plows by now, but Austin said a bid issue stalled the purchase.

“They would have helped immensely, I’m going to be very honest. You know, if we had those 27 extra we would have been able to get our arterial streets done more quickly and then get into the residential streets more quickly.”

But despite the complaints, despite the loss of two additional school days, don’t look for Columbus to match Kansas City’s plowing fleet.

Austin said it would be cost prohibitive.

“I am in no way dismissing the frustration of not being able to get out of your driveway, if that is the case, or if your street needs plowed…but we’re talking about an event in Columbus, this kind of a snowfall, that maybe happens once or twice a year. So for once or twice a year to invest that kind of money into equipment and personnel is not a good return on our investment,” she said.

If you’re counting, Columbus’s 43 inches of snow this winter is double our average amount. And snow is in the forecast for Thursday.

Comments
  • disqus_Rrj1iJCDh1

    “In last week’s storm [Columbus] used 78 plows… Kansas City put 240 plows on the street last week, more than double what Columbus used.”
    Um, then that would be more than triple.

    • WOSU Public Media

      Fixed! Thanks for pointing that out. The number of plows Columbus used decreased and we forgot to update the comparison.

    • TM

      to be fair, they didn’t say how much more than double it was. ;)

  • 333SAL

    Over a decade ago, there were similar snows that kept many residential streets with significant coverage until the melt, weeks later. It was obvious that the City had no intention of plowing them . . . ever. It was very difficult to get out of driveways, much less the streets. And the worst were in poorer areas of town. Many of us complained and were given the same line of propaganda as now . . . the “events” are too few and far between.

    Personally, I don’t think that the frequency of “events” is as relevant as the weeks of inconvenience which follow. It can tie up traffic for a significant part of the winter. And it’s embarrassing to have the wealthy suburbs in comparison. It’s a cavalier attitude by City government and it should stop. At the same time that we were deficient in street clearing, many plans were being made for less critical “improvement” projects, such as street beautification and the notorious chicanes that were later removed at public protest. Granted, matching money is probably not available for snow plows, but we do have an emergency fund.

    With global warming and the increasing unpredictability of weather, it is important that we stay on top of it. And vote your opinion. When this happened years ago, I vowed to not vote again for the current administration. And I stuck to that vow. We need to remember these things.

  • Big Country

    I live in the Short North. The City of Columbus Public Service loves to tow and ticket everyone they can but refuse to plow the roads. Sounds about right.

  • katastrophe

    BREAKING: GROUCHY PEOPLE WITH CABIN FEVER FIND MORE REASONS TO COMPLAIN ABOUT THE WEATHER, GOVERNMENT

    property owners are responsible for their own sidewalks, BTW. I’ve found the pedestrian experience anywhere but downtown to be far worse than the driving experience.

  • sleepyo

    The mayor does not care any more. The last Mayor he attacked because he didn’t get the streets cleaned and now he is repeating the same behavior. Our Mayor needs to go.

  • JR

    The city could raise some funds for more plows if they enforced the fines for residents who were too lazy to shovel their own sidewalks…

  • Given_Up

    The roads between Riverside Drive and Sawmill Road in Columbus (not Dublin) south of 161 are **still** not cleared. I can’t tell if since the beginning of the season if they received even a single pass from snow plows. It’s the worst I have seen it on 6 years.