A task force studying Ohio police and community relations has narrowed down list of potential recommendations.
Mug Shot Website Owners Protest Extortion Allegations
Listen to the Story
They are a part of every arrest: the humiliating, unflattering mug shot. Once they are taken, the pictures are public records and remain on file at the sheriffâ€™s office or police station. But now in the digital age, the pictures donâ€™t stay in a file cabinet. A number of websites collect the mug shots and use them to make money. As WOSUâ€™s reports, the consequences can be long-lasting, even for the innocent.
A basic Google search of his own name led Julian Cennamo, to a ten-year-old picture heâ€™d just as soon forget. Itâ€™s his mug shot.
â€œI made a foolish and immature mistake that a lot of young folks do,” Cennamo said.
Cennamo, from Canal Winchester, drove drunk. He was 22.
â€œThatâ€™s very long in my past.â€
He contacted the mug shot website, and just like that, they took down the photo. But Cennamoâ€™s booking picture popped up on another mug shot website. And this time, removal would come at a price.
â€œSeveral hundred dollars to remove the photo which I certainly would not do and was not happy about,” he recalled.
Cennamoâ€™s picture remains on the site along with thousands of other mug shots.
Websites like bustedmugshots.com and justmugshots.com collect thousands of booking pictures from police stations and sheriffâ€™s offices. The posts usually include the charges, personâ€™s age and arrest location.
Some websites charge up to $400 to have the pictures removed if the person meets certain criteria such as the person was found not guilty of the charge, it was a non-violent crime, or if the person in the mug shot dies.
â€œThere is a crime called extortion,” said Toledo attorney Scott Ciolek.
Ciolek has filed a class action lawsuit against five website operators, including bustedmugshots.com and justmugshots.com.
â€œYou have committed this crime when you demand money in return for not embarrassing someone even if the information that you would otherwise embarrass them with is truthful,” he said. “You are not permitted to demand money in return for not doing that.â€
Ciolek also alleges the websites violate Ohioâ€™s corrupt activities and publicity laws.
Ciolek said he has heard from about 2,000 people who say their personal and professional lives have suffered because someone stumbled across their mug shot.
â€œWeâ€™ve heard about people not being hired, losing jobs, not being allowed credit, not being allowed to move into rentals,” he said. “[People] setting up dates for themselves only to have someone Google their name to find out that theyâ€™ve been charged with something.â€
Ciolek said would-be employers or dates generally do not go directly to the websites. Instead, they find the mug shots through Google searches.
Google is making it harder to find mug shots by dropping them down the list of search results.
Texas attorney Joseph Centrich represents Citizens Information Associates, the owner of bustedmugshots.com and another site named in the suit.
Centrich said itâ€™s not extortion because the company has not threatened or contacted anyone. He maintains the sites simply offer a public service.
â€œThe mug shot got taken for a reason. Maybe you were found not guilty. Thatâ€™s great,” Centrich said. “But it still happened, and itâ€™s a newsworthy event. And to the extent that those records are public, then the public has a right to know.â€
Arthur Dâ€™Antonio III is CEO of justmugshots.com. He also denied claims of extortion. And Dâ€™Antonio said the website no longer will accept money to remove booking pictures.
â€œThereâ€™s a lot of morality questions around a model like that. And we struggle with those same morality questions ourselves,” D’Antonio said. “At the end of the day, we try to do what we think is best for the public, and so weâ€™re going to do our best to going to try to be a long-term business that doesnâ€™t have to rely on what some people feel is an immoral business model.â€
Since the lawsuit was filed, Centrich said his clientâ€™s sites stopped charging a fee to remove a mug shot. A quick check of mugshotsonline.com notes it is re-working its removal policy. And Dâ€™Antonioâ€™s justmugshots.com has temporarily disabled paid removals.
Still, Julian Cennamoâ€™s mug shot remains on a couple of sites, though it did not pop up in a simple Google search. Nevertheless, Cennamo, whoâ€™s an artist, worries potential clients could find it one day.
But he was quick to note he has come a long way since that mug shot was taken a decade ago.
â€œThe good thing is that if you do search my reputation online youâ€™ll find out that I have a very strong reputation,” Cennamo said.