Veteran journalist Carl Hoffman believes he’s solved one of the great mysteries of the 20th century. In 1961 at the age of 23, Michael Rockefeller – son of New York Governor Nelson Rockefeller and a member of one of the richest and most powerful families in America ¬– travelled to remote New Guinea in search of primitive art for his father’s new museum.
Cleveland Neighborhood Hopes To Recover From Ariel Castro Horror
Listen to the Story
Three months ago, the international media zeroed in on the near west side Cleveland neighborhood where Ariel Castro held three women captive for a decade. Castro pleaded guilty Friday to hundreds of charges of rape, kidnapping and aggravated murder — and once again, the television cameras returned to Seymour Avenue. Residents are hoping that this time, the media gets the story of their neighborhood right.
The Rev. Horst Hoyer was tolling the bells at Immanuel Evangelical Lutheran Church just as the tweets went out: Castro was pleading guilty to 937 of the 977 charges against him – and faces life plus 1,000 years in prison.
His are the same bells that toll every Sunday. Including the more than 500 Sundays when Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus and Michelle Knight were held captive in a frame house just four buildings west on Seymour Avenue. Hoyer takes a small bit of comfort in that.
“And there was one thing that Mr. Castro could not stop from coming into that house and into the rooms of those good ladies, and that was the sound of the bells that we have up in the tower here. Every Sunday, twice, they heard them,” Hoyer says.
Hoyer’s church hall became a staging site for police, sheriff’s deputies, FBI agents and other investigators who descended on the area when Berry broke free of Castro’s house early on the evening of May 6th and led police to the other two.
Until that night, Hoyer says no one in the neighborhood had a clue.
“Well, all I can say is Mr. Castro would make a terrific actor. He played a perfect role of Dr. Jeckel and Mr. Hyde. I don’t think anybody in the neighborhood had any suspicion. Had we known, anybody would have pitched in, anybody would have been a neighbor,” Hoyer says.
But that’s not the way he and others say their neighborhood was often portrayed. Instead, they heard accounts of an area pockmarked by crime, decay, vacant houses and indifference. It’s a description Herman Wetzel says he doesn’t recognize. And he’s lived in the area for 84 years.
“This is just a normal neighborhood in the city of Cleveland and all this about all the theft and everything. There’s not of that going on around here. This was the only bad scene here,” Wetzel says.
Neither Wetzel nor others diminish how horrific that scene was, nor the trauma the women suffered.
“Time is an every rolling stream. You don’t stop it. And the time that they have lost is devastating. My feeling is, if harm is done, it could be healed. But the scare will remain forever,” says Hoyer.
The actual sentencing of Castro will be next Thursday. But Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Michael Russo has made clear the parameters – Castro will never be freed. And the house on Seymour – now boarded up and surrounded by a 10-foot chain-link fence – is forfeited and will be torn down.
Immanuel Lutheran’s secretary Jill Kurschner says that’s important for everyone.
“You know after it happened it took me the longest time to just to drive down the street to even just drive past the house because I just couldn’t wrap my head around what happened,” Kurschner says.
Castro pleaded guilty after Cuyahoga County prosecutors promised they would not pursue the death penalty in connection with Castro forcing one of the women to repeatedly miscarry. Through their lawyer, all three have repeatedly said they did not want to testify at a trial. And after the plea, their statement said, they were relieved and continue to be grateful to the community for its support, and for leaving them alone.